Editorials and Opinions
Editorial: Our Top 10 Mayoral Attributes
Editorials and Opinions
Editorial: Keep it RFK Stadium
News & Politics
Editorial: Georgetown’s Design Review Takes a Hit
News & Politics
Opinion: Are Streateries Still Cool or a Disaster Waiting to Happen?
News & Politics
Editorial: Life Lessons from … John Candy
Arts Education at Fillmore Under Attack — Again!
• February 24, 2016
Washington, D.C.’s public school system is once again attacking music, art and drama, and threatening to take away the very programs that kept thousands of families in the city to send their kids to public school. Showing a lack of support for arts education and furthering the squeeze on five overcrowded schools, DCPS is proposing to cut all funding from its 2016-17 school year budget for Fillmore Art Center. Fillmore provides arts education to more than 1,700 students from three wards and will be forced to close if DCPS has its way.
Students from Key, Ross, Marie Reed, Hyde-Addison and Stoddert elementary schools attend Fillmore for a half-day each week to receive arts education. If funding for Fillmore is not restored, the popular and much-loved arts center will close, making it impossible to provide this invaluable, enriching arts education.
Each of those schools is currently over capacity and/or in transition without permanent space. Fillmore provides an off-site dedicated location for arts education and allows the schools to pool their resources, ensuring high-quality arts programming that could not be replicated within any one school.
DCPS has taken no steps to prepare the families for Fillmore’s dismantling. There is no realistic plan or contingency for arts education that would even come close to the quality instruction the children receive at Fillmore.
DCPS should be working to fix things in the system that are broken — not cutting programs that are proven and successful for schools that are already enrolled well beyond their capacity. The Fillmore partnership is effective and cost efficient. DCPS is unfairly penalizing the kids and parents from these schools.
The children who attend Fillmore deserve a well-rounded education, just like every other student in the city. If DCPS wants to encourage families to keep their kids in its schools, they need to stop playing slash-and-grab with the cost-effective programs that work.
Please help us say no to DCPS’s latest efforts, by visiting www.friendsoffillmore.org for more information.
John Claud is the president of Friends of Fillmore Arts Center.
A Trip to Cuba
•
President Barack Obama is scheduled to visit Cuba March 21 — a trip that has raised predictable political hackles. (To say nothing about Gitmo.)
Less problematic, at least in terms of public opinion, is the Cuba trip by Washington, D.C., Mayor Muriel Bowser and a host of regional leaders, officials and District leaders in conjunction with the Hispanic Chamber of Commerce on a historic exploratory mission.
One of Bowser’s stops on the trip, scheduled to run through Thursday, was the University of Havana, where her mission (and certainly that of D.C. Public Schools Chancellor Kaya Henderson, also a member of the delegation) was to find how Cuba’s literacy, graduation rates and university and college retention rates remain consistently high. “Washington, D.C., has seen great gains in our education system,” Bowser said. “Given Cuba’s emphasis on a strong education, I know there’s a lot we can learn from each other.”
Bowser met with her counterpart, Marta Hernandez Romero, the mayor of Havana. “As one of the first U.S. city delegations in decades to visit Havana, we have put ourselves in a position to form a positive working relationship that we hope will benefit our region in years to come,” Bowser said.
With 41 persons on the trip, there must be a lot to learn from a country with which the United States is on the way to normalizing relations. Council members Jack Evans and Vincent Orange are on hand, as are Montgomery County Executive Ike Leggett and Virginia Secretary of Commerce and Trade Maurice Jones.
Yes, sí, we’re all in this together. What’s next? How about a Washington Nationals exhibition game in Havana?
Making the Right Homeless Decisions
•
When Mayor Muriel Bowser, members of her team, and an assortment of local and regional public officials (along with the journalists covering them) return from their Cuban sojourn, they need to roll up their sleeves and decide how best to implement the mayor’s homeless housing plan.
Just about everybody in the city agrees that closing down D.C. General as a homeless shelter would be a good thing, long overdue. And if not a celebration, certainly there was praise in many quarters for Bowser’s (and former mayor Vincent Gray’s) plan to create a series of “smaller, dignified facilities” — in other words, temporary shelters spread throughout the city, in each and every one of the eight wards, a kind of share-the-pain-and-gain approach.
But the shelter locations, and how they were chosen, have already stirred up some opposition — not an unexpected development, given that there are always “we like the idea but not in my neighborhood” naysayers. Under the best of circumstances, even when voted for (as we’ve found in recent months and years), change runs into speed bumps and potholes.
The mayor anticipated opposition, which seems these days to be coming from Wards 1 and 5 and parts of Ward 3 and Ward 4. The reasons are sundry. Ward 5 representative Kenyan McDuffie remains one of the few Council members unhappy with the proposals. Other opponents complain about a lack of transparency in the site-selection process, into which they claim to have had no input. McDuffie said the site in his ward is very close to other social service facilities.
The mayor’s plan proposes seven shelters in seven wards (Ward 2 already has a women’s shelter). These sites would require extensive renovations, making for a somewhat lengthy process. However, some sites could begin to house homeless residents as early as next year. As sites become fully functional, the closure of D.C. General will be within reach.
One site has already come under heavy criticism from the public and the press: 2266 25th Place NE in Ward 5. According to nearby residents, this address, which is slated for 50 units, is in an industrial area with few stores or other conveniences. One resident said that it’s an industrial wasteland, next to a strip club.
While the mayor has said she’s not budging on the plan, the question ought to be asked: How does a location like that help those who are most in need of help?
A Big Snow Storm That Let Us Get Small
• February 18, 2016
Washingtonians will remember the Blizzard of 2016. It was a blizzard for the ages, as trumpeted the Washington Post whose Sunday paper came on Monday but come it did and whose weekend magazine came on Friday, and come it did—came but did not let go.
Officially, for Washingtonians and others in the area, it ended on Jan. 23 just before midnight. The snow stopped, and we woke up the next day to sunshine and a pile of snow so high. Hardly anyone went out, and we became stale air breathers for a time.
The storm was awesome in its fury, its tonnage and created tundras and caused us to start worrying in a serious way. Weather folks and measurers and which doctors exulted—they had been for once right, and couldn’t wipe the smile off their faces. This was their time—they even dressed for it. Pat Collins came out with his stick and schtick. It seemed, in spite of everything, that all was all right with the world, as best as it could be.
The storm wiped out—if not the sun—other news for the most part. Lots of people ventured out, even though Mayor Muriel Bowser sternly told them not to. They went to the nearest pub, whatever remained open, a restaurant, a street corner, just to see, to get bee-stung by wind-swept snow, to look at the sights, holding hands or to roll in the snow.
This past weekend was a time when the most viral sight was of a middle aged black and white bear sucking his toes as he rolled in the snow with all the delight of a cub.
Another sure sign that while there was tragedy tonight, while cars got stuck, and people crashed into each other, and some died in a multistage catastrophe—41 feet there, 22 right in our back yards, 29 in Baltimore—there was heart-felt feeling of having once again survived. Not everyone or everything did—roofs collapsed, lights went out, the homeless suffered casualties as they always do, we all went to sleep not quite sure on Saturday night what we might wake up to.
We get warped views of these things—narrow-eyed, only outside the steps, the chatter on the streaming computer, the sirens, the snow, the snow. And so we become our own best friends, shut-ins. We listen and watch for the round of reporters out in Virginia and Maryland, standing guard with reports at gas stations, neighborhood stores, impassable and impossible intersections, shivering, some, their long hair in tatters, others looking sharp and fashionable, trudging the roads against the odds.
We salute you guys: wouldn’t want to be you.
My son called from Anaheim, sunny Los Angeles for once, on a job setting up convention media, for a convention of rock-and-roll music instrument buyers and sellers, I think, I’m not sure. It sounded cool, you go, son. He asked if we were okay, thinking about us and all that. We said it hasn’t stopped snowing and that it’s going to get worse. The tone of his voice was frowning—you don’t need Skype for that.
The television never went off—what a wonder, and through it, through our over-provisioning, we made piles of noodles and meatballs and a hot breakfast. The panda appeared on the screen regularly, as did the stuck truckers. Outside on Sunday on Lanier Place, tourists—we believe—had somehow ventured onto our street and gotten stuck. Dogs were being walked, and the little statue of Mother Mary at Joseph’s House had been wrapped in double layers of scarves, red against the white snow.
On television, we sectioned out on reruns: “Blue Bloods,” “SVU,” “NCIS,” “Friends” and comfort food.
In times like these, the world almost disappears: I did not hear the word “Syria” or “Obamacare.” We become smaller.
First, the newspapers disappear for two days, an odd thing not to look for the paper in the pile of snow. The world out there disappears with it. Oh, we can follow the doings of the British Parliament if we want, but who wants to. The Kardashians seem to have gone off the grid, also, unless you are looking. The Middle East is too warm, sunshine on their weapon-carrying shoulders. Putin has nothing to say.
The only people who have something to say are the politicians, the office-runners, still with us, Donald Trump with his daily output of outrageous stuff—”I could shoot someone on Fifth Avenue and it wouldn’t lose votes,” dissing Barbara Bush, trying to rekindle a feud with Megyn Kelly, and, of course, battling with the prince of darkness Ted Cruz. Cruz, these days, looks a little mangled, which is the look of that old song “I fought with Trump and I think he’s winning, where the hell are my boots.”
It’s hard to let go of them and their importuning ways—the first votes to be cast will be cast just about any February day now and the procrastinators and protesters, and anti-procreators and predictors, and rotor rooters are spinning their wheels. What if, and if this happens, and those people go to a caucus and another one sits on a caucus and can’t vote, why we could be looking at President Trump. This is what the Sunday morning shows do to you. You can’t look away, it’s the opposite of viral, some blue addiction. Bernie and Hillary and Marco and the Donald and all those experts and reporters following them all like rabbits.
It’s enough to make you watch old movies. We watched “The Outlaw Josey Wales” and were surprised to remember what a fine old western and movie movie it is, a kind of homage by Clint Eastwood to John Ford, bloody, to be sure, but a kind of tall tale, too, like “True Grit” and “Little Big Man” with the steadying commentary of Chief Dan George. It seemed like every grizzled old face that had ever graced—grizzly and all—a western.
In this atmosphere, in these times of white fallout and inundation, people running for office seem like intrusions, flies around a bone, buzzing needlessly and uselessly.
Let the music play, help your neighbor, say hello to your neighbor, sing a song of sixpence, that’s what’s important. In the silent night, should you wake up in the dark, remember a friend or a song, and say goodbye again. Watch the children and small dogs in the snow. Kiss your wife and the window.
Make an angel in the snow. Watch your breath in the cold. Pray for the people along the flooding, churning Atlantic.
Drown out for a few days the noise of the chattering classes trying to drown out the sound of your breathing—those who claim they know you and what you want.
Happy 60th, Mike Copperthite
•
Mike Copperthite’s 60th birthday party took place at Martin’s Tavern where a bunch of his friends stopped by to visit him at the booths in the Dugout on Jan 6. Drinks and fun were had by well-wishers. He was his usual exuberant self, proud of his wife and daughter, and proud of the newest wall plaque at Martin’s, which celebrates his relative, Henry Copperthite, as D.C.’s “Pie King” and celebrates Walter Johnson as one of the greatest pitchers of the Washington Senators.
Copperthite, a political strategist and a descendent of the founders of the Connecticut-Copperthite Pie Company, resurrected the baking of Copperthite pies in 2012 — one of the largest businesses in Washington a century ago (with a bakery at Wisconsin Avenue and O Street NW and one on Capitol Hill). He is often seen about town delivering his pies, mostly as donations to such places as St. John’s or the Georgetown Senior Center. He even restored a 1914 Model T Connecticut-Copperthite Pie Company delivery truck, and donated it to the Smithsonian.
We’re glad to wish Mike a Happy Birthday for his love of Washington history and of Georgetown. We know that — even at 60 — he has no “off” switch. So, don’t even try.
Former Publisher Dave Roffman: Survivor
•
David Roffman, former editor and publisher of The Georgetowner, retired to the Gulf Coast six years ago. He and his wife Carmen are living and loving the beach life, taking it easy every day with their two big dogs. Washington seems so far away now — not that Roffman has stopped commenting about politics and American life. Nevertheless, one never knows what excitement retirement can bring. The following is an update from our favorite old guy.
I was just elected president of our homeowners association. There are 290 homes in our Ashford Park community, which is in Foley, Alabama — on the Gulf Coast, near Mobile.
On my first day as president, on Jan. 12, I was holding my first meeting with the newly elected board of directors when two guys brandishing guns entered the home and announced, “Everybody down. This is a holdup!”
There were eight of us at the meeting, almost all senior citizens. I stood up and faced them with a gun pointed right at my stomach and said, “This could take a while. It’s hard for us to get down … let alone get back up again.” True story.
One of the seniors started to scream, another ran down the hall and jumped out of the bedroom window, and the two perpetrators ran outside chasing him. We locked the doors and called the police. A few hours later, after a robbery at the nearby Walgreens parking lot, the police caught the guys — two 18-year old punks who were former football players at Foley High School. The cops booked them and their bail was set at $100,000 each. They had been on a crime spree all the way from Texas, according to WKRG-TV Channel 5, which also interviewed me and others about the crime.
How’s that for my first day in office? Just like old times in Georgetown, when I was Crime Prevention Chairman for the Citizens Association of Georgetown. (And, by the way, bring back Au Pied de Cochon!)
Fear and Snowing on the Campaign Trail: The 2016 Campaign and the Days of Our Lives
• February 10, 2016
Somewhere out there in the vast expanses of the American electoral map, there are some hearty souls—maybe three, maybe a dozen—who are saying, “I told you so,” after Donald Trump and Bernie Sanders made victory speeches in New Hampshire for winning their respective Republican and Democratic primaries.
Anybody predicting this scene a year ago would have been jeered at and mocked even in the darkest corners of the Internet. Whoever predicted this outcome probably won the most recent Powerball lottery and should be investigated.
Yet, here we are: Donald—”Let’s Make America Great Again”—Trump and Bernie—“A Future to Believe in”—Sanders, not only winning but running away with their respective races in a state famous for its ambush-style, contrarian, heavily independent-in -spirit, -thought and -action voters.
Sanders trashed the odds-on, all-but-anointed-favorite Hillary Clinton and the Clinton machine by more than 20 points. Trump, who was a loser to the evangelists’ favorite, Ted Cruz, in Iowa—ran away from the Republican field, which saw nice-guy, moderate Republican, Ohio Governor John Kasich, rise to temporary viability with a surprising second-place finish.
Watching this process play itself out has become an increasingly surreal experience. Lots of things happen in the background, history marches apace, but more and more the primary process and its endless series of debates has begun to overwhelm the news of our daily lives. Economic figures, terrorist attacks, wars and refugees, black lives matter and immigrants have become and been often reduced to talking points for the various men and women who woke in the middle of some night—when they were seven or 70—from a vivid dream in which they had had one hand on the Bible and the other raised upward, saying, “I . . . fill-in-the-blank . . . do solemnly swear . . .”
There were 16 Republicans who had that dream, fewer remaining to still believe it, and there will probably be fewer still after this second round of actual voting.
New Jersey Governor Chris Christie, after carving up Florida Senator Marco Rubio like a pot roast during the last GOP debate, was rewarded with a negligible 7 percent of the vote, just ahead of businesswoman Carly Fiorina and befuddled brain surgeon Ben Carson, who was last seen still waiting to be called to the podium. For Carson, it was a long fall from his high point. Was it just yesterday or the month before that he had shared the lead in the polls with Trump?
It’s fair to say that ever since Trump announced that he was a candidate for president by calling for a wall that he would but on Mexico’s credit card and talked about rapists streaming across the border, that we have lived in Trump World. As a result, our electoral process has become a kind of three-ring circus of polls, debates, world events as talking points, debates and more debates, punctuated by Trump gaffes, outrageous remarks and proposals, after which Trump would again rise in the polls. Trump has turned the whole process upside down, obliterated a G.O.P. establishment which had planned for a Jeb Bush nomination—more or less—or some other rising conservative star like Rubio.
The rise of the gnomish Sanders has been less acrimonious but just as improbable. He is after all a self-described Socialist-Independent-Democrat, a senator from Vermont with a not particularly spectacular legislative record, 74 years old and not getting younger. To Hillary Clinton followers, he must have seemed an annoying little speed bump in her road to the presidency. Instead, in New Hampshire, he won by 20 points and captured 80 percent of the under-30 vote as well as big support from gun owners and women. Go figure.
Both Trump and Sanders, it’s been noted, have tapped into what everyone sees as a hugely angry voter population—angry about jobs and the lack thereof, angry about values, angry about middle class erosion, angry about the one percent, angry about terrorists, immigrants, America’s standing in the world and, evidently, most angry about political correctness.
Somewhere in there, though, we have marched into the Land of Oz, the carnival, the circus.
If we were not in Kansas, we did get into Iowa, which is a similar place, a land of caucuses and corn, where Trump got all the attention for not appearing in a debate and a relished showdown with blonde-ambition moderator Megyn Kelly. Iowa became a place where up was down, where a third-place finish by rising Rubio had him sniffing the steps of the White House, where a near-tie between Bernie and Hillary had Clinton claiming victory — and, while Cruz won the G.O.P. caucuses, it was Trump who got the last word, at first gracious, and then claiming that Cruz had cheated.
There were more debates to come before the N.H. primary. Sanders and Clinton engaged in impolite battle on the Democratic side on a Friday, and as for the Republicans, it was the Chris Christy show, where Jeb Bush once again was the only person on the dais taking on Trump and the Donald trying to shush him, literally. That debate took place on Saturday night, when good people should be out having dinner or imbibing something or other. Any notion that this was not the year for that was dispelled when you found Bernie in a “Saturday Night Live” skit on the Titanic.
In Washington, the city still spent time recovering from the blizzard of 2016—all those pockets of dirty snow piles slowly disappearing. Out in the wide world, there were attempts at Syrian peace talks, which were failing, and North Korea tested a long-range missile, which led to much saber-rattling among G.O.P. debaters. In Hollywood, folks were talking about boycotting the Oscars over a lack of diversity in the acting nominations—no African Americans for the second year in a row—while the Super Bowl proved to be a washout for North Carolina’s super-star with the dance and the pants Cam Newton. None of the news—including two particularly horrific murders in the area—could quite compete with Iowa and New Hampshire.
None of the news, in the end, could quite compete with Trump. The media did its usual thing, gathering around tables and predicting or dissecting results like fussy first-year medical students around a still-warm corpse. But inevitably while they pondered what suddenly vulnerable Rubio might do, or how the Clintons would recover their lost mojo, or how Bernie would do in South Carolina, or if Kasich could survive his new-found political prosperity, the mike, the notebook, the attention always turned to Trump.
Trump did not disappoint. As a parting shot, he urged voters “even if you’re dying or your wife is leaving you” to vote. He became involved in using a sexist P-word at a rally, and suddenly, Trump’s vulgarity became an issue in not one but two NBC interviews. Trump, said he was just repeating what a woman had said at a rally, and in any case, he was “just having fun” — and anybody that would object, well, it’s P.C.
Political correctness has always been Trump’s magic bullet and cover for just about any sort of behavior or comment, from mocking a reporter’s disability to making fun of Sen. John McCain, when he was a U.S. Navy aviator for becoming a prisoner of the North Vietnamese in 1967 to the Kelly contratemps.
On NBC News, veteran legend and reporter Tom Brokaw bemoaned the lack of civility in politics. He’s right, but it’s not coming back.
We’re not just not in Kansas anymore. You can’t ignore that man behind the curtain any more. Goodbye, New Hampshire.
Hello, South Carolina.
And wait, there’s more: Super Tuesday is March 1.
My Fantasy: Conventions With Real Drama
•
Please indulge me in my ultimate political fantasy. To date, I have attended 16 national political conventions: 11 Democratic and five Republican. At each and every one, the presidential nominee was selected on the first ballot.
I desperately want to go to a convention where it takes more than one ballot to get the prize. The last time that happened? For the Republicans, 1948, and for the Democrats, 1952. (To be perfectly clear, I didn’t make it to either of those gatherings.)
In 1948 in Philadelphia, Thomas E. Dewey was the GOP presidential nominee. You may recall that Alice Roosevelt Longworth memorably described Dewey as “the little man on the wedding cake.” In 1952 in Chicago, the Democrats nominated the governor of Illinois, Adlai E. Stevenson. Stevenson was erudite and witty, and there was a genuine draft to get him to run.
A little history is relevant to my fantasy. For you readers who crave convention minutia: Franklin D. Roosevelt was nominated in 1932 on the fourth ballot, Warren G. Harding was nominated in 1920 on the 11th ballot and, in 1924, the granddaddy of them all, John W. Davis was nominated on the 103rd ballot. (You read that right.)
In recent political memory, there have been some attempts to break out of the first-ballot groove. In 1960, John F. Kennedy barely made it when Teno Roncalio of Wyoming put him over. In 1976, Ronald Reagan nearly sent Gerald Ford into the second ballot. Then, in 1980, Ted Kennedy tested Jimmy Carter.
Most conventions are pre-ordained and wholly scripted — coronations, not contests. Everyone knows who the nominee is going to be. No suspense, no surprises.
What I want is for both parties to have conventions with drama. The Republicans will gather in Cleveland July 18 to 21. I’m hoping that no one gets the required 1,237 delegates — not Trump, not Cruz, not Rubio. Let the aspirants duke it out on the convention floor. Let’s see some real action for a change: horse-trading, maneuvering, finagling, the works.
The same, I hope, will occur in Philadelphia, where the Democrats will meet July 25 to 28. Imagine that both Sanders and Clinton fall short of the magic number of 2,382 delegates. Maybe a new candidate will step forward, seeking to take advantage of the turmoil … Joe Biden … Sen. Elizabeth Warren … a complete dark horse like Sen. Sherrod Brown of Ohio … the possibilities are endless!
That’s the way it should be.
In the summer of 1948, Philadelphia hosted not one but four political conventions; Dewey was the nominee of the Republicans, Truman of the Democrats, Wallace (Henry, not George) of the Progressives and Thurmond of the Dixiecrats. The last time the Republicans met in Cleveland was 1936. They nominated Alf Landon for president and carried two states in the November election. (Perhaps that’s an omen for the elephants.)
Above all, let’s bring back the smoke-filled rooms, the challenged delegations, the favorite sons, the long, rambling nominating speeches, the floor demonstrations — with gavel-to-gavel coverage that will grab you and keep you enthralled for four fabulous days.
That’s my dream.
Political analyst Mark Plotkin is a contributor to the BBC on American politics and a contributor to TheHill.com. Reach him at markplotkindc@gmail.com.
Take Time for Black History
•
February is Black History Month, which, given the times, still receives an unduly lesser amount of attention from the media and probably from us all. The occasion — the consideration of achievements, events and times in black history — is sometimes treated with diffidence and coolness by black and white people alike, perhaps because it seems a sort of set-aside, something out of the stream of history, time and even forgetfulness.
It’s perfectly true that elements of black history — those events that might remain otherwise unnoticed, such as the heroics of black fighter pilots in World War II, the exploits of players from the Negro Leagues, or the critical role of black women in the civil rights movement — are worth considering specifically, and probably for entirely different reasons in each case. (In Washington, there is an especially rich African American history, known well by black and white alike.)
We suspect the problem that some people have with black history is that there are circles and lines around it, including Keep Out signs. That particular history, some of it hidden, seems to be about black history in the context of the generic history, but however you might pursue its study, it’s also the history of all of us.
Politics, culture and society often try to separate people from one another, to urge a kind of unhealthy self-interest, at the expense of others. Somewhere in our travels, or early in life and at its last, we realize that however deprived or however entitled we might be, our history begins and ends the same way — in the womb and on a deathbed — and in this way, however separated, we are never truly apart. Surely, “I have a dream” — its urgency speaks to everyone, not just one people.
Celebrating black history is important — without it, no one can truly celebrate their own lives or understand it fully. The best way to study history is at the places where all lives intersect. History is everyone’s lives moving forward, not necessarily in tandem. Just this past week, sports junkies were studying the style of a single black athlete and his clothes — and arguing about it. In these days too, the slogan on a T-shirt that “Black Lives Matter” still resonates and does not require the counter, that “All Lives Matter.”
In the meantime, save the date for the opening of the National Museum of African American History and Culture on Sept. 24 — with America’s first black president front and center.
2016 Sounding Like the Year the Music Died: Now, Glenn Frey
• February 1, 2016
These days, we’re having more than a few “days the music died.”
Natalie Cole seems like a little while ago. David Bowie, just last week. Glenn Frey.
Frey, co-founder with Don Henley (his collaborator and best bud, no question) of the Eagles, the soulful, rock-and-country-tinged super band-hit machine of the endless summers of the 1970s, died Jan. 18 at the age of 67 from complications from rheumatoid arthritis, acute ulcerative colitis and pneumonia.
Henley, who issued the evocative solo album, “Cass County,” last year, said, “He was like a brother to me, we were family, and like most families, there was some dysfunction. But, the bond we forged 45 years ago was never broken, even during the time when the Eagles were dissolved. … Glenn was the one who started it all. He was the spark plug, the one with the plan. … We are all in a state of shock and disbelief and profound sorrow. … I will be grateful every day, that he was in my life… Rest in peace, my brother, you did what you set out to do, and then some.”
A mega-rock band, is still a group, so that when one of its members passes, there’s a temptation to go into tribute mode for the whole band. With Frey, it’s probably entirely appropriate to do just that. While and Henley wrote co-wrote many of the songs, and the band members—the originals were Frey, Henley, Randy Meisner, Bernie Leadon, Don Felder, Joe Walsh and Timothy B. Schmit, Frey was probably its most dynamic, charismatic and resonant member, who set the band’s tone.
That tone and that amalgam of talent over the years produced a huge number of just downright perfect hit songs, in the 1970s songs that were particular but also universal mode, one that was hard-driving, full of rueful melancholy, romantically cynical, regretful about last night, eager for the next night. Their music was one of the most successful attempts to marry rock attitude and beats to the best and most resonant kind of country content, tinged with frayed cowboy hats, hangover blues and stretches of long highways with road stops at diners and clubs and somebody else’s bedrooms.
Run that list through your mind sometimes: if you heard one of their songs, you’re bound to hear them a thousand times, same as ever, the lyrics going into your blood stream like a straight shot of pure, 30-year-old scotch.
Here you go start your engines, alphabetically: “Already Gone,” “Best of My Love,” “Desperado,” “Doolin-Dalton,” “Guilty of the Crime,” “Heartache Tonight,” “Hotel California,” “How Long,” “I Can’t Tell you Why,” “I Don’t Want to Hear It Anymore,” “James Dean,” “Life in the Fast Lane,” “Long Road Out of Eden,” “Lyin’ Eyes,” “One of These Nights,” “Peaceful Easy Feeling,” “Take It Easy,” “Take It To the Limit,” “Tequila Sunrise,” “The Long Run,” “Wasted Time,” “Witchy Woman.” You get a drift in just the song titles, of what it was like for them in the 1970s and beyond. Frey was long considered the Warren Beatty of rock and roll and did not shy away from drugs.
The Eagles always seemed to be on the verge of breaking up and eventually did, only to reform years later and tour again.
But the two versions, while much the same, in terms of the music, didn’t quite look the same, especially Frey.
Look at them, those early Eagles. They appear as if they came out of the shade of the summer of love, the long hair, the eager playing, the frayed shirts, all of that tanned look, but the guitar rolls are the same, and the pretty blonde hippie madonnas in the audience are bopping up and down. Years later, here they are again, Frey, minus the beard, a friendly but craggy look, short hair, pink shirt, blue suit, playing hard, singing with soul and clarity and the same girls are out in the audience, with their boyfriends (now their husbands?), smiling knowing smiles at the lyrics. In later life, Frye, who had a solo career, was into fitness and health food, looked like a guy who could give a power-point talk.
First point: Take It Easy.
Last point: Take it to the Limit.
He did both—personified it all.
